This April, Warner affiliate About
Records (www.aboutrecords.com)
set out to track their flagship artist, Tim Hockenberry, who writes,
arranges, plays terrific keys, doubles on trombone, and sings like a hybrid
of Joe Cocker and Ray Charles. Tim’s a total pro in front of the mic onstage
and in the booth, but producer George Daly wasn’t happy with the results
they were getting from the Nashville studio they had used for demos. The
band array wasn’t unusual: bass, guitar, drums, vocals, and Tim’s Yamaha
P120 digital piano. They, like you, were after the best of both worlds: the
feel of a live concert and the audio quality of a studio recording.
Enter Skywalker Sound, George Lucas’
state-of-the-galaxy post-production facility in the verdant hills of Marin
County, 45 minutes north of the Golden Gate Bridge. The virtual tours at
www.skysound.com will
hint at why the record company decided to pony up for a recorded live
concert on the facility’s main scoring stage. Just the band, 100 lucky
guests, and the hors d’oeuvres. The force was definitely with them.
Tim and his crew were lucky to secure
Skywalker’s director of music and scoring, Leslie Ann Jones, as their
recording engineer for the session. Much of America’s musical zeitgeist in
the last 25 years has flowed through the faders under the talented fingers
of Ms. Jones, who’s worked with everyone from Herbie Hancock to Miles Davis
to Carlos Santana. As a teenage musician in Los Angeles, she got her
industry start renting out her PA to other acts and doing sound for their
gigs and sessions. So the live music ethic is in her blood — and she
generously gave us unfettered access to her process.
THE GEAR
Every note came through high-end mics
and direct boxes into an assortment of preamps, a Neve 88R mixing console,
then Digidesign Pro Tools. During tracking, Jones employed minimal EQ, and
no compression or limiting. Boutique preamps included Neve model 1081s and
an Avalon VT-737SP on Tim’s lead vocal.
From the analog outputs on the Pro
Tools interfaces, raw signal was routed to a 56-channel Clark sound
reinforcement board at the rear of the room. So there were two completely
independent mixing consoles — one for recording and one for live sound.
In addition to each instrument having
its own track in ProTools, Leslie also tracked a pair of Neumann TLM-170
mics that were hung relatively close to the PA speakers, and a classic and
coveted AKG stereo mic, the C24, in the back of the theater to capture
audience sound. She also ran a live stereo mix into a 1/2" analog tape
recorder and a CD recorder to give the artists and producers a rough mix to
listen to on their drive home.
What didn’t Leslie use? A
high sample rate, for starters — the Pro Tools session ran at 24 bits and
44.1kHz. Her only significant compromise was to swap out her prized (and
enormous) Telefunken vocal mic for a small but high-quality Neumann KMS-105
that let the audience see Tim’s face. Since the usual tools of acoustic
isolation — gobos, baffles, putting guitar amps in an isolation booth, and
so on — would have interfered with the musicians’ eye contact, not to
mention a concert-like stage presentation, the production team didn’t use
them. As it turned out, separation between tracks was greater than expected
because of the sheer size of the scoring stage: A rule of thumb is that the
bigger the room, the less of a problem reflections pose to close-miked
instruments.
THE TECHNIQUES
Bummed that your band can’t afford a
musical Valhalla? Don’t be. Here are some tips for getting a strong
recording when you can’t show up on George Lucas’ doorstep.
If at all possible, don’t try to
engineer and play at the same time. If you have a recording rig that’s
independent of the live mixing console, hire, beg, or blackmail someone to
run it while you perform, give them an accurate set list with song
descriptions, and make sure to flag who takes what solos in what order. Even
better, have them rehearse with the band at least for one set, so they can
better anticipate dynamic shifts and instrument changes. If the live console
is part of your recording chain, give the live engineer a well-annotated set
list, 50 bucks, and buy his or her drinks for the night. It can’t hurt.
What about overloads? In a real-world
situation, you probably won’t have enough compressors for every channel in a
multitrack recording. But you can put one trusty compressor/limiter on the
lead vocal. Set it for a fast attack to catch the occasional spike. (See
“Compressor Crash Course” and “Dynamic Priorities” at
www.keyboardmag.com/0707110 for more on compression during live
recording.) You can also put an extra mic on the vocalist, at a lower gain,
and not assign it to the main live mix. The sound tech can ignore this
track, but if you find places in the primary track with digital distortion
when you play back the raw take, you’ve got a backup track to mix forward.